- An Enzyme's Unusual Biochemistry
- Scientists Maneuver Robot Through Living Lung
- Microstructure of Two-Phase Materials
- Sustainable Energy for Aviation
- GM Silkworms Spin Super-Strong Spider Silk
- Bug-Sized Robots Can Leap, Lift and Race
- Electronic-Grade Van Der Waals Te Thin Films
- Brain Inspires More Robust AI
- Personalizing 3D-Printable Models
- Sensing and Control Integration in Soft Robots
- Researchers Make Strides in Harnessing Low-Grade Heat for Efficient Energy Conversion
- Battery-Free Robots Use Origami to Change Shape in Mid-Air
- Hot Summer Air Turns Into Drinking Water With New Gel Device
- Important Connectivity of Metal Oxides With Hydrogen
- 'Brainless' Robot Can Navigate Complex Obstacles
- Breakthrough in Scarless Wound Recovery Achieved With Autologous Blood
- 3D-Printed 'living Material' Could Clean Up Contaminated Water
- Wood Modification Boosts Biomass Conversion
- Atomically-Precise Quantum Antidots Via Vacancy Self-Assembly
- A System to Keep Cloud-Based Gamers in Sync
- An 'introspective' AI Finds Diversity Improves Performance
- New AI Technology Gives Robot Recognition Skills a Big Lift
- AI Enabled Soft Robotic Implant Monitors Scar Tissue to Self-Adapt for Personalized Drug Treatment
- Robustness of the World's Skyscrapers Stress-Tested
- Tiny, Shape-Shifting Robot Can Squish Itself Into Tight Spaces
- Paving the Way for Advanced Quantum Sensors
- Vision for Future Micro-Optical Technology Based on Metamaterials
- Sensors Harnessing Light Give Hope in Rehabilitation
- Care Robots: Ethical Perceptions and Acceptance
- The Physics of Fat Droplets Reveal DNA Danger
- Researcher Finds Inspiration from Spider Webs and Beetles to Harvest Fresh Water from Thin Air
- AI Helps Robots Manipulate Objects With Their Whole Bodies
- New Framework for Oceanographic Research Provides Potential for Broader Access to Deep Sea Scientific Exploration
- New Dual-Arm Robot Achieves Bimanual Tasks by Learning from Simulation
- Do Measurements Produce the Reality They Show Us?
- Research Group Detects a Quantum Entanglement Wave for the First Time Using Real-Space Measurements
- Engineers Use Kirigami to Make Ultrastrong, Lightweight Structures
- Want to Know How Light Works? Try Asking a Mechanic
- Advancing Trajectory Tracking Control of Pneumatic Artificial Muscle-Based Systems
- Groundbreaking Green Propane Production Method
- Decoding How Molecules 'talk' To Each Other to Develop New Nanotechnologies
- Nanoscale Material Offers New Way to Control Fire
- Riding a Wave to Better Medical Diagnosis
- Self-Driving Cars Can Make Traffic Slower
- Arrays of Quantum Rods Could Enhance TVs or Virtual Reality Devices
- AuNi Alloy on Au Electrodes for Hydrogen Evolution Reaction: Towards a Cleaner Tomorrow
- Quantum Material Exhibits 'non-Local' Behavior That Mimics Brain Function
- Self-Supervised AI Learns Physics to Reconstruct Microscopic Images from Holograms
- Discovery in Nanomachines Within Living Organisms -- Cytochromes P450 (CYP450s) Unleashed as Living Soft Robots
- Modified Virtual Reality Tech Can Measure Brain Activity
- Robots Cause Company Profits to Fall -- At Least at First
- Super Radar: Breakthrough Radar Research Overcomes a Nearly Century-Old Trade-Off Between Wavelength and Distance Resolution
- New Method Simplifies the Construction Process for Complex Materials
- Thermal Imaging Innovation Allows AI to See Through Pitch Darkness Like Broad Daylight
- Scientists Create Novel Approach to Control Energy Waves in 4D
- Building Blocks Spontaneously Construct 3D Objects in Fluids
- 3D Display Could Soon Bring Touch to the Digital World
- Imaging Shows How Solar-Powered Microbes Turn CO2 Into Bioplastic
- Novel Raman Technique Breaks Through 50 Years of Frustration
- Engineering Team Uses Diamond Microparticles to Create High Security Anti-Counterfeit Labels
- Reinforcement Learning Allows Underwater Robots to Locate and Track Objects Underwater
- This 3D Printed Gripper Doesn't Need Electronics to Function
- Researchers Develop Low-Cost Sensor to Enhance Robots' Sense of Touch
- New Technology Promises Rapid and Reliable Development of New Diagnostic Tests
- A Simpler Method for Learning to Control a Robot
- Robotic Hand Rotates Objects Using Touch, Not Vision
- AI Can Ask Another AI for a Second Opinion on Medical Scans
- A Butterfly's First Flight Inspires a New Way to Produce Force and Electricity
- New Robot Boosts Solar Energy Research
- Towards Artificial Photosynthesis With Engineering of Protein Crystals in Bacteria
- 'Quantum Avalanche' Explains How Nonconductors Turn Into Conductors
- Robot Preachers Get Less Respect, Fewer Donations
- Using Our Oceans to Fight Climate Change
- Researchers Investigate New Use for Plastic Bottles
- Device Makes Hydrogen from Sunlight With Record Efficiency
- Allowing Robots to Explore on Their Own
- Researchers Put a New Twist on Graphite
- Bioengineered Yeast Feed on Agricultural Waste
- Staying Sharp: Researchers Turn to an Everyday Shop Tool to Study How Materials Behave
- A Faster Way to Teach a Robot
- Bot Inspired by Baby Turtles Can Swim Under the Sand
- Robotics: New Skin-Like Sensors Fit Almost Everywhere
- Improving Urban Planning With Virtual Reality
- Researchers Establish Criterion for Nonlocal Quantum Behavior in Networks
- Analogous to Algae: Scientists Move Toward Engineering Living Matter by Manipulating Movement of Microparticles
- New Material Could Hold Key to Reducing Energy Consumption in Computers and Electronics
- Researchers Develop Approach That Can Enable Inexpensive Mass Manufacturing of Micro-LED Displays
- A Ferroelectric Transistor That Stores and Computes at Scale
- Robot Team on Lunar Exploration Tour
- Generative AI 'fools' Scientists With Artificial Data, Bringing Automated Data Analysis Closer
- Pump Powers Soft Robots, Makes Cocktails
- Training Robots How to Learn, Make Decisions on the Fly
- Researcher Turns One of the Basic Rules of Construction Upside Down
- Revolutionary Self-Sensing Electric Artificial Muscles
- The Science Behind Skipping Stones
- The Ground Is Deforming, and Buildings Aren't Ready
- Navigating the Future of Underwater Geolocalization: How Polarization Patterns Enable New Technology
- AI Nursing Ethics: Viability of Robots and Artificial Intelligence in Nursing Practice
- Researchers Grow Precise Arrays of nanoLEDs
- Testing Real Driverless Cars in a Virtual Environment
- New Study Shatters Conventional Wisdom and Unlocks the Future of Electrochemical Devices
- AI-Based Technique for Predicting Crystal Orientation Improves the Efficiency of Manufacturing Most Electronic Devices
- Fast, Automated, Affordable Test for Cement Durability
- AI and CRISPR Precisely Control Gene Expression
- Robotic Glove That 'feels' Lends a 'hand' to Relearn Playing Piano After a Stroke
- Transferring Data With Many Colors of Light Simultaneously
- New Single-Photon Raman Lidar Can Monitor for Underwater Oil Leaks
- Turning Old Maps Into 3D Digital Models of Lost Neighborhoods
- New Method Could Break Down PFAS Left on Water Treatment Filters
- Emulating How Krill Swim to Build a Robotic Platform for Ocean Navigation
- LATEST NEWS
- Top Science
- Top Physical/Tech
- Top Environment
- Top Society/Education
- Health & Medicine
- Mind & Brain
- Living Well
- Space & Time
- Matter & Energy
- Business & Industry
- Automotive and Transportation
- Consumer Electronics
- Energy and Resources
- Engineering and Construction
- Textiles and Clothing
- Inorganic Chemistry
- Organic Chemistry
- Energy Technology
- Alternative Fuels
- Energy Policy
- Fossil Fuels
- Nuclear Energy
- Solar Energy
- Wind Energy
- 3-D Printing
- Civil Engineering
- Forensic Research
- Materials Science
- Medical Technology
- Robotics Research
- Sports Science
- Transportation Science
- Virtual Environment
- Weapons Technology
- Wearable Technology
- Albert Einstein
- Nature of Water
- Quantum Computing
- Quantum Physics
- Computers & Math
- Plants & Animals
- Earth & Climate
- Fossils & Ruins
- Science & Society
- Education & Learning
- Strange & Offbeat
- Gravity's Effect On Antimatter Revealed
- New Light On Strange Lava Worlds
- Decreasing Biodiversity: Spread of Viruses
- Did Life Exist On Mars? Other Planets?
- Atmosphere and Star of an Exoplanet
- Hidden Supermassive Black Holes Reveal Secrets
- Gulf Stream Weakening Confirmed
- Peopling of Europe: Pleistocene Warming Spell
- Upgrading Iron, Steel Plants: Huge Carbon ...
- Ritual Use of Human Remains During Neolithic
France Eyes Toll Road Tax to Boost Transportation Investment Plan
Toll road operators are preparing to fight the proposed tax, which would raise an estimated $630 million in its first year.
US Supreme Court to Review Agencies' Ability to Interpret Law
At the start of its 2023-2024 session on Oct. 2, the U.S. Supreme Court has not yet set a date to hear arguments in a major case that could reevaluate the authority federal agencies have to interpret ambiguous language in U.S. law in rulemaking.
California To Be Key Buyer of Floating Offshore Wind Energy
The state announced it would purchase uncontracted energy to sell to utilities to propel the market, as key developer Equinor launches the first undersea robotic analysis and design of its deepwater project site off Morro Bay.
Pulse for the Week of October 2, 2023
Information from Pulse is derived from the Dodge Construction Network, the most powerful source of information, insights, and connections in the commercial construction industry.
Saudi Arabia Shortlists Contractors for $1B in Solar Power Projects
Five of 15 domestic and international bidders are shortlisted to build two photovoltaic projects with a total capacity of 1,500 MW.
Prices Level Off for Used Machines as Manufacturers Sort Out Supply Chain Issues
While shopping around for a used piece of construction equipment through the usual channels has taken some creative sourcing in recent years, this summer has seen prices stabilize for the most part.
Craftworker Wages Continue to Rise Amid Labor Shortages
Labor shortages and inflationary pressures continue to push up craftworker wages with recent settlements trending toward levels not seen in decades.
3Q Confidence Index: Positivity Grows Among Construction Executives
ENR’s Construction Industry Confidence Index rose this quarter to its highest rating since Q1 of 2022, up six points to a nearly stable 46 rating.
High Interest Rates, Labor Woes Persist in Third Quarter
As the construction industry continues to grapple with the difficulties of the last several years, some sectors have fared better than others, and experts predict there is still some time to come before these issues have been settled.
Construction Economics for October 2, 2023
ENR’s 20-city average cost indexes, wages and materials prices. Historical data and details for ENR’s 20 cities can be found at ENR.com/economics
The latest news and information
#1 source for construction news, data, rankings, analysis, and commentary.
Copyright ©2023. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.
Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing
- Share full article
Years of Delays, Billions in Overruns: The Dismal History of Big Infrastructure
The nation’s most ambitious engineering projects are mired in postponements and skyrocketing costs. Delivering $1.2 trillion in new infrastructure will be tough.
When completed, the Cedar Viaduct project that runs through the Central Valley in Fresno, Calif., will carry high-speed rail over State Route 99. Credit... Patrick T. Fallon/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images
By Ralph Vartabedian
- Nov. 28, 2021
As Honolulu sprawled into new suburbs west of Pearl Harbor over the last two decades, city planners proposed an ambitious rail transit line that would sweep riders 20 miles into downtown. The $4 billion estimate in 2006 was hardly cheap, amounting to $200 million per mile.
The cost escalation since then has been an engineering marvel all its own. Concerns over Native Hawaiian burial grounds stalled early construction, then problems with welding and cracks in the tracks appeared. Earlier this year, engineers realized that in some sections, the wheels were a half-inch narrower than the rails. Order new wheels? Tear up the tracks?
The launch dates slipped forward and the cost estimates crept upward — at latest count, $11.4 billion, with a target completion date of 2031.
Honolulu’s tribulations are far from a lone cautionary tale. To the contrary, they signal the kind of cost overruns, engineering challenges and political obstacles that have made it all but impossible to complete a major, multibillion-dollar infrastructure project in the United States on budget and on schedule over the past decade.
As the nation sets out on a national spending spree fueled by the $1.2 trillion infrastructure bill signed by President Biden this month, the job ahead carries enormous risks that the projects will face the same kind of cost, schedule and technical problems that have hobbled ambitious efforts from New York to Seattle, delaying benefits to the public and driving up the price tag that taxpayers ultimately will bear.
American cities and states were long renowned for some of the greatest bridges, water systems and freeways in the world, but challenges have grown more potent. Agencies have less internal technical talent. Legal challenges have grown stronger under state and federal environmental laws. And spending on infrastructure as a fraction of the economy has shrunk, giving local agencies less experience in modern practices.
The $1.2 trillion package has bold goals, directing the majority of $500 billion to highways, $39 billion to urban transit, $65 billion to broadband projects and $73 billion to electrical grids, among other items. The nation’s busiest passenger rail line, Amtrak’s Boston-to-Washington corridor, would get the biggest slice of a $66 billion rail package. The infrastructure spending plan is unlikely to rescue some existing infrastructure projects that are bogged down with problems.
And even with the new infusion of money, analysts say it will be tough to ramp up infrastructure progress as swiftly as envisioned in the current timetable.
The construction industry is facing sharply growing costs for steel products, up by 142 percent in the last 12 months, and other key materials. Shortages of skilled labor are worsening, exacerbated by Covid-induced retirements.
“A lot of people would like to see the money quickly spent,” said Anirban Basu, chief economist of Associated Builders and Contractors, a construction industry trade group. “They are going to look at the costs they are facing and extend out the projects because of constraints.”
Bent Flyvbjerg, a professor at the University of Oxford who has studied scores of projects around the world, found that 92 percent of them overran their original cost and schedule estimates, often by large margins — in part, he said, because cost estimates are “ systematically and significantly deceptive .”
“A lot of projects are not delivering what they promised to deliver,” he said.
In Baltimore this month, Mr. Biden lamented that U.S. infrastructure was once rated the world’s best and now, “You know what we rank in infrastructure? Thirteenth in the world. ”
In some cases, U.S. construction costs are higher than those in Western Europe and democratic nations in Asia, according to an upcoming University of California, Berkeley, analysis, said Ethan Elkind, a law professor and director of the school’s climate program.
“It is a lot harder to build projects here, and we are not as skilled at doing it,” he said.
When California voters approved a bond in 2008 for a high-speed rail system from Los Angeles to San Francisco , the project was supposed to cost $33 billion and be completed by 2020 . The job is now projected to finish in 2033 for $100 billion, though those estimates are dated and there is an $80 billion funding gap.
The ambitious project, the nation’s most serious effort to build a full-scale bullet train, has encountered serious delays because of land acquisition issues, environmental litigation, permit setbacks, employee turnover and significant design changes. The problems have triggered political infighting even with the Democratic supermajority in California.
Lengthy delays have also affected New York’s East Side Access extension of the Long Island Rail Road, which is supposed to cut up to 40 minutes off commuter time on the last segment, from Queens to Grand Central Terminal, with up to 24 trains per hour at peak times.
Conceived more than a half century ago, with a construction contract awarded in 2006, that project was supposed to be completed by 2011. Early estimates put the cost at $2.2 billion, then $4.3 billion in 2006 and $6.4 billion in 2008. The Metropolitan Transportation Authority now envisions completion in December 2022 at a cost of $11.1 billion. Design changes, underground tunneling problems and coordination with other agencies were some of the factors in the delays and cost increases.
One of the nation’s most important environmental infrastructure projects, and perhaps the most technically difficult one, has been underway in Central Washington State for decades at the former Hanford nuclear weapons site. Since 2013, major construction has been stopped at two partially built plants to treat and vitrify 56 million gallons of radioactive sludge.
When an independent review in 2015 found 362 significant design problems, the Energy Department announced a 17-year delay and estimated the system would become fully operational in 2036.
The problems included the failure to anticipate the potential for an earthquake to damage equipment and the possibility that the chemical processes to separate high-level radioactive materials could cause explosive hydrogen gas to form.
The delays have pushed the Energy Department to adopt an alternative that would start treating low-level waste by the end of 2023, Washington State officials said. The last cost estimate for the plant was $17 billion, up from $12.3 billion in 2013 and about $4 billion 20 years ago.
The rail project in Hawaii was intended to relieve congestion on a par with Los Angeles along the urban band from East Kapolei to the core of Honolulu.
The Honolulu Authority for Rapid Transportation believes it can address the latest track problems by welding certain sections of track and later replacing wheels to match the track size, said a spokesman, Harry Cho.
The setbacks that resulted in delays — archaeological surveys, labor costs, utility relocations and land acquisition — are the kind of challenges that plague nearly all major infrastructure projects; the common mistake is in not planning and budgeting for them, said Joseph Schofer, a Northwestern University civil engineer and originator of the “Infrastructure Show” podcast.
“You can’t say these were an accident,” he said of most cost overruns. “We could do better. We haven’t gotten honest estimates in a lot of cases.”
Mr. Schofer said many projects are justified by estimating that future benefits will exceed costs, but when the costs go up astronomically, no one recalculates the ratio.
In a candid admission of how the political world operates, Willie Brown, the former mayor of San Francisco, once dismissed cost overruns on a transportation hub intended for the bullet train.
“In the world of civic projects, the first budget is really just a down payment,” he wrote in a guest newspaper column in 2013 . “If people knew the real cost from the start, nothing would ever be approved. The idea is to get going. Start digging a hole and make it so big there’s no alternative to coming up with the money to fill it in.”
U.S. Transportation Department officials declined to comment for this article, but Biden administration officials have said the new infrastructure package will redress decades of neglect and will boost the efficiency of the American economy, address climate change and provide immediate jobs in construction.
“We’re going to reduce congestion,” Mr. Biden said. “We’re going to address repair and maintenance backlogs, deploy state-of-the-art technologies and make our ports cleaner and more efficient.”
Mr. Flyvbjerg, the Oxford professor, said infrastructure keeps getting more expensive at a time when many products, such as televisions, refrigerators and computers, get cheaper or better each year.
“Big infrastructure is becoming cost prohibitive,” he said, a problem he blames on institutional sclerosis at government agencies that keep repeating mistakes and choose infrastructure projects that are unlikely to succeed.
The mistakes, he said, include a lack of transparency to the public, flawed contracts that put government agencies at the mercy of contractors and a failure to attract enough private investment to bear some of the project’s risk.
The new infrastructure law, he said, does little to change the outlook.
Ronald N. Tutor, chief executive of Tutor Perini, a California firm that is building some of the nation’s largest projects, said the industry has done a good job of advancing and completing projects that by their nature are complex and unpredictable.
“All the major projects have cost and schedule issues,” he acknowledged. “The truth is these are very high-risk and difficult projects. Conditions change. It is impossible to estimate it accurately. That is naïve.”
The infrastructure law takes some initial steps at reforms, including codifying a Trump executive order to name a lead federal agency for each project, reducing the number of chefs in the kitchen, said Diana Furchtgott-Roth, who formerly oversaw Transportation Department research and technology and now is a George Washington University adjunct professor.
A key factor is the amount of time federal agencies spend to review environmental reports and issue records of decision, she said. In many cases, she said, projects are put on hold for years, while agencies review voluminous documents.
Mr. Biden also named a task force to carry out the infrastructure program with an aim to “invest public dollars efficiently, avoid waste and focus on measurable outcomes for the American people.”
The environmental review process has become so complex, in part to defend against inevitable lawsuits, that neither state agencies nor federal departments can write and review the documents without teams of outside consultants.
Most of the spending under the $1.2 trillion infrastructure plan has been previously authorized, but the law includes $550 billion of new money to be spent in as little as five years.
Federal, state and local agencies were working their way through $270 billion a year in authorized spending in 2019, before the pandemic hit. An attempt to bump that up by an additional $100 billion annually, as envisioned, represents a 37 percent jump that may not be possible to achieve, industry analysts warn.
“It is a very big bump,” said Ken Simonson, chief economist at Associated General Contractors of America, which represents major infrastructure builders. “My guess is that we are not going to see $550 billion spent in the first five years.”
Save $10 on digital!
Engineering 1420 articles archived since 1845
Streetlights Are Mysteriously Turning Purple. Here’s Why
Newly purple streetlights might seem innocuous, but they could affect driver and pedestrian safety
Introducing Scientific American ’s Redesign, Newsletter and Podcasts
Geoengineering is happening, AI wants to talk with animals, and why we aren’t going to live in space
Dams Worldwide Are at Risk of Catastrophic Failure
Here’s why disasters like Libya’s dam collapses happen and how to prevent them
New Air-Conditioning Technology Could Be the Future of Cool
Standard AC units cool buildings but contribute to global warming. New technology aims to change that
Science, Destroyer of Worlds—And Movie Scripts
Oppenheimer won’t bomb in the box office, but despite its director’s best efforts, the science in the film is a bit of a fizzle
How Empty Office Spaces Can Be Converted into Homes
It is possible to transform empty office buildings into residential ones—but remodeling these spaces won’t be easy
Science Reveals How to Roll the Perfect Joint
Researchers used a smoking machine to test the intensity of marijuana rolled into joints
Where Are the Worst Bridges in the U.S.?
More than 42,000 highway bridges across the country are in “poor” condition, according to national bridge inspection standards
See How Crushing Pressures Increase in the Ocean’s Depths
If the missing Titan submersible was near the Titanic when it imploded, it would have experienced pressure higher than that of a great white shark bite
50, 100 & 150 Years Ago: June 2023
Computer chess master; private bathing for birds
50, 100 & 150 Years Ago: May 2023
King Tut’s bountiful tomb; music from fire
The NYPD’s Robot Dog Was a Really Bad Idea: Here’s What Went Wrong
Design, context and timing influence whether humans embrace a robot or reject it
50, 100 & 150 Years Ago: April 2023
Artificial rain; a scientist lives on Vesuvius
Nord Stream Pipeline Blasts Stirred Up Toxic Sediment
The Nord Stream pipeline explosions happened in a dumping ground for chemical warfare, but other contaminants proved most toxic to marine life
Why Is It So Hard to Make Vegan Fish?
Futuristic food science technology could finally bring plant-based salmon filets and tuna steaks to the table
New Color-Changing Coating Could Both Heat and Cool Buildings
A thin film can switch from releasing heat to trapping it, and wrapping the coating around buildings could make them more energy-efficient
How to Engineer Buildings That Withstand Earthquakes
Though deadly quakes can’t be prevented, science does have some ways to protect buildings—and the people inside them
New Exascale Supercomputer Can Do a Quintillion Calculations a Second
New “exascale” supercomputers will bring breakthroughs in science. But the technology also exists to study nuclear weapons
Flavor-Enhancing Spoons and Chopsticks Could Make Food Taste Better
New types of cutlery can enhance flavors such as sweetness or saltiness for a more satisfying meal
Mighty Morphin’ Turtle Robot Goes Amphibious by Shifting Leg Shape
A turtle-inspired robot can morph its legs to move from land to water and back
Support science journalism.
Thanks for reading Scientific American. Knowledge awaits.
Already a subscriber? Sign in.
Thanks for reading Scientific American. Create your free account or Sign in to continue.
See Subscription Options
Continue reading with a Scientific American subscription.
You may cancel at any time.