temporary job vs permanent

• Skip to primary navigation
• Skip to main content
• Skip to footer

4 Corner Resources

Hiring Temporary vs. Permanent Employees: Benefits & Disadvantages

June 19, 2023 | Recruiting Insights

When it’s time to hire, you have two main options: onboard a permanent employee who will be part of your team for the long haul, or opt for a temporary worker who can help meet your needs on a short-term basis. Which should you choose? This article will help you decide on hiring temporary vs. permanent employees.

Differences Between Temporary vs. Permanent Employees

Temporary employees.

Temporary employees, sometimes called temps, include freelance and contract employees and workers hired through an employment agency. 

They’re employed for a limited, predetermined amount of time, like during a company’s busy holiday season. Or, they may be brought on indefinitely with the understanding that the arrangement is not permanent, like when a full-time staffer is out on medical leave but plans to return. 

A temporary employee is paid an agreed-upon rate for their work, typically via an hourly wage or a contracted fee. They’re not usually eligible for benefits like employer-sponsored healthcare, retirement, and paid time off. Some temporary employees, like freelancers, are fully responsible for their own taxes. 

Permanent employees

Permanent employees include both full- and part-time employees who work for a company in an ongoing capacity. In other words, there’s no predetermined end date for their employment. 

Full-time permanent employees are eligible for any benefits the company provides, and some companies include part-timers in this offering as well. Employers are responsible for a portion of their permanent employees’ taxes and things like unemployment insurance and worker’s comp in some states. 

Pros of Hiring Temporary Employees

Cost-effective.

Purely from a dollars-and-cents perspective, it’s generally more affordable to hire a temporary employee than a permanent one. This is because the only wage-related cost of temporary employees is their compensation, whereas permanent employees also bring costs in the form of taxes and benefits. 

Specialized expertise

Temporary employees allow you to access specialized knowledge without the expense of hiring a full-time employee. 

For example, let’s say your agency lands a major marketing campaign, and part of that campaign involves building a niche mobile app. If you don’t already have developers in-house, bringing onboard a full development team would be very expensive. 

Instead, most agencies would opt to leverage temporary workers to provide those technical skills for only the duration of the campaign, greatly saving on labor costs while still meeting the business’ needs.

Opportunity for a “trial run”

One of the toughest parts of hiring is accurately gauging what a person will be like to work with day in and day out. Temporary work arrangements give employers the unique opportunity to actually see how a candidate does the job firsthand before making an offer for permanent employment. 

And, if the company does decide to make an offer, the temporary employee is already ahead of the game as a new hire because they have some prior knowledge of the company’s workflows and culture. 

Builds talent pipeline

Suppose you treat temporary workers with the same appreciation and respect you give to permanent employees. In that case, you can build valuable relationships that can benefit you in the future in the form of viable candidates for long-term positions. 

Temporary workers are often in between opportunities–figuring out their next career move or paying the bills while they earn their degree, for example. If a permanent position becomes available, one of your temps might be the perfect candidate, whether next month or sometime further down the road. 

Not only does this help you hire quickly, but reduces the cost associated with tracking down brand-new talent.

Related: How to Build a Talent Pipeline

Cons of Hiring Temporary Employees

Extended time-to-productivity.

Temporary employees require the same training as permanent employees, and often more because they might not have any prior experience in the field. This means it typically takes them longer to get fully up to speed in a role, and their employment may end soon after reaching full productivity. 

This can mean the company spends more onboarding and training multiple temporary employees versus just one permanent staff member. 

Higher turnover potential

A temporary employee who’s looking for permanent work could leave at any time for a better opportunity or even a higher-paying temp role. 

Moreover, not all temps are looking for a full-time job; some temporary employees opt for temp work because it’s noncommittal. While both parties in a temporary work agreement enjoy the benefit of flexibility, the company also risks losing a temp at any time, for several reasons.

Related: Highly Effective Strategies for Employee Retention

Reduced engagement 

Temporary employees don’t usually have the same “buy-in” to a company’s culture as its full-time workers. The nature of temp work means some employees are in it strictly to collect a paycheck rather than trying to make a meaningful investment in a company’s mission. 

Also, some temps work for multiple employers, so you may not get 100% of their focus or energy.

Increased cost per hour

Because temporary workers don’t receive the same benefits and tax contributions as their permanent counterparts, they often come at a higher hourly rate. When deciding whether hiring a temporary or permanent employee makes more financial sense, you’ll need to carefully consider the duration and scope of the work you need to be done to see if the hourly rate is practical. 

Pros of Hiring Permanent Employees

Increased engagement.

Permanent employees presumably applied for their position because they wanted to work at the company, not just because they needed fast cash or were assigned to the gig through a temp agency. Thus, permanent workers tend to invest more in doing a good job. They also can advance within the company, which motivates higher performance.

Workforce stability

Because permanent workers are, well, permanent, they make a bigger contribution to a company’s knowledge base. They have more time to accrue job-specific knowledge and refine their workflows, which can result in better output. 

Lighter recruiting workload

Once you’ve landed a permanent employee, you won’t have to fill that position again for a long time. This is in contrast to temporary positions, which may need to be filled multiple times consecutively.  

Contributes to strong culture

Permanent employees can develop meaningful relationships with their coworkers, which leads to a sense of belonging. They also have time to build an intrinsic connection to the company’s mission, strengthening their commitment to the organization. Both of these things contribute to a positive company culture. 

Cons of Hiring Permanent Employees

Added expenses.

When considering the cost of PTO, health insurance, retirement plans, taxes, training, and development, permanent employees are usually the more expensive hiring option.

Related: How to Reduce Hiring Costs

Up-front commitment

Hiring is an investment. In fact, it’s one of the most expensive activities a company engages in. When you make an offer to a permanent employee, you’re taking a greater financial risk than with a temporary worker. There’s more on the line if it doesn’t work out. 

It’s more difficult in most states to fire a permanent employee, with added legal considerations, paperwork, and costs. 

Recruitment challenges

Identifying and attracting talent for permanent positions is typically more challenging than filling temporary roles, especially in a tight labor market. Plus, you’re up against competition from similar employers. The longer it takes to hire, the more hiring costs and labor increase. 

To combat these challenges, you must continually refine your recruiting strategy to optimize the hiring process as much as possible.

Related: Common Recruitment Challenges and How to Overcome Them

Should I Hire a Temporary or Permanent Employee?

Here are some scenarios where hiring each type of worker might make sense. 

You might want to hire a temporary employee if you…

• Have a short-term project that requires niche skills
• Need to beef up your workforce to meet seasonal demands
• Need coverage for a permanent employee who is on maternity or medical leave
• Want to test out a candidate before making an offer for permanent employment 
• Are going through a phase of rapid expansion

You might want to hire a permanent employee if you…

• Need someone to cover a consistent, ongoing set of duties
• Require a specific skill set to achieve long-term goals
• Are incurring increasing overtime costs in a certain department or skill area
• Are looking to build your leadership team

Ultimately, making a careful analysis of your budget, timeline, required skills, and overall objectives will help you make the best decision about which type of employee to hire.

Enjoying our articles? Get the latest straight to your inbox.

About Pete Newsome

Pete Newsome is the President of 4 Corner Resources, the staffing and recruiting firm he founded in 2005. 4 Corner is a member of the American Staffing Association and TechServe Alliance, and the top-rated staffing company in Central Florida. Recent awards and recognition include being named to Forbes’ Best Recruiting Firms in America, The Seminole 100, and The Golden 100. Pete also founded ze ngig , to offer comprehensive career advice, tools, and resources for students and professionals. He hosts two podcasts, Hire Calling and Finding Career Zen, and is blazing new trails in recruitment marketing with the latest artificial intelligence (AI) technology. C onnect with Pete on LinkedIn

Related Posts

10 Must-Haves in An Independent Contractor Agreement

Large vs Small Business: The Differences When Hiring Employees

Top Tips on How to Be a Successful Recruiter

• Career Blog

Pros and Cons of Temporary Jobs: A Complete Guide.

Temporary jobs have become increasingly popular in today’s economy, offering both flexibility and opportunity. In this article, we will provide a comprehensive guide to the pros and cons of temporary jobs.

Temporary jobs are positions that are contracted for a specific length of time, including seasonal, project-based, or short-term assignments. These jobs may be full-time or part-time, and they typically offer a variety of benefits and drawbacks.

Brief history of temporary jobs

The history of temporary jobs dates back to the early 1900s when staffing agencies began to emerge. During World War II, the government relied heavily on temporary workers to meet the increased demand for manufacturing and other essential services. Since then, the temporary job market has grown significantly, with many companies opting to hire contract or freelance workers instead of traditional employees.

Importance of temporary jobs in today’s economy

Temporary jobs have become increasingly important in today’s economy for several reasons. These positions offer flexibility for workers who may desire a work-life balance, need to supplement their income, or are in between permanent jobs. Additionally, businesses are increasingly turning to temporary workers to fill positions quickly, especially during peak seasons or periods of high demand.

Advantages of Temporary Jobs

Temporary jobs are becoming increasingly popular among job seekers due to the many advantages they offer. Not only do temporary jobs provide a flexible work schedule, but they also offer opportunities for gaining new skills, networking, and higher pay rates. In this section, we will discuss these benefits in more detail.

A. Flexibility

One of the most significant advantages of temporary jobs is the flexibility they provide. Temporary workers can often choose their own schedules, making it easier to manage other obligations or responsibilities. If you are a student, a caregiver, or someone looking for extra income, temporary jobs can be an excellent way to earn money without sacrificing your other commitments.

B. Opportunities for Gaining New Skills

Temporary jobs are an excellent way to gain new skills and experience. Employers often seek out temporary workers for specialized projects or one-time assignments, which can provide unique opportunities to learn and grow. These jobs can help you build your resume, gain experience in new industries, and develop new skills that you can use in your future career.

C. Networking Opportunities

Temporary jobs can be an excellent way to expand your professional network. Often, temporary workers are brought on as additional support during busy seasons or projects, which means they have more opportunities to work with a diverse group of people. This can be especially valuable for individuals who are starting their careers and looking to build connections in their industry.

D. Higher Pay Rates

Temporary jobs can also offer higher pay rates than traditional full-time positions. Employers often offer temporary workers higher salaries or hourly rates to compensate for the lack of job security or benefits. Temporary workers can use this additional income to help pay off debt, save for future expenses, or enjoy more flexibility in their personal lives.

Temporary jobs offer many advantages to job seekers looking for flexibility, diverse experiences, professional connections, and increased pay rates. However, it’s essential to consider the potential downsides of temporary work, including job uncertainty, lack of benefits, and limited opportunities for advancement. By carefully weighing the pros and cons, you can determine if temporary work is the right choice for you.

Disadvantages of Temporary Jobs

Temporary jobs offer many benefits to both employers and employees. However, as with any type of employment, there are also some drawbacks that should be considered. In this section, we will discuss the most significant disadvantages of temporary jobs.

A. Lack of job security

One of the most significant disadvantages of temporary jobs is the lack of job security they provide. Temporary employees are often hired for short-term projects or to help cover busy periods, which means that they may not have a job once the project is complete or the busy period subsides.

This lack of job security can be especially challenging for those who rely on a steady income to pay bills or support their families. Temporary employees may find themselves constantly searching for new job opportunities, which can be stressful and time-consuming.

B. Limited benefits

Another disadvantage of temporary jobs is the limited benefits they offer. Temporary employees may not have access to the same benefits as full-time employees, such as health insurance, retirement plans, and paid time off.

This lack of benefits can make it challenging for temporary employees to manage their finances and plan for the future. Additionally, they may not have access to the same support system as full-time employees, which can be especially challenging in times of need.

C. Uncertainty about future employment

Temporary employees may also experience uncertainty about future employment. Because they are often hired for short-term projects, they may not know when their current job will end or if they will be offered future opportunities with their current employer.

This uncertainty can make it challenging for temporary employees to plan for the future and can lead to feelings of anxiety and stress.

D. Less job satisfaction

Lastly, temporary employees may experience less job satisfaction than their full-time counterparts. Because they are often hired for short-term projects or to cover gaps in staffing, they may not have the same level of investment in their work as full-time employees.

Temporary employees may feel disconnected from their work and their colleagues, which can lead to a lack of job satisfaction and motivation.

While temporary jobs offer many benefits, including flexibility and the ability to gain experience in different industries, they also present some significant disadvantages. These include a lack of job security, limited benefits, uncertainty about future employment, and less job satisfaction. It’s essential to consider these factors when deciding whether a temporary job is the right fit for you.

Types of Temporary Jobs

Temporary jobs come in different forms, each with unique characteristics and requirements. Here are the most common types of temporary employment:

A. Seasonal Jobs

Seasonal jobs refer to work opportunities that are available only during specific times of the year. Examples of seasonal jobs include holiday gift wrapper, park ranger, lifeguard, and tax preparer. These types of jobs are ideal for students or individuals who need to supplement their income during an off-peak season. But, it also means that there may be periods of unemployment or underemployment.

B. Contract Jobs

Contract jobs are temporary positions that have a specific starting date and end date, often for a specific project or task. Contract jobs are more common in industries such as engineering, consulting, and information technology. These types of jobs often offer higher pay rates and more flexibility in terms of work hours, location, and work content. However, contract workers are not eligible for benefits, and may have a harder time finding new contracts after their current one ends.

C. Freelance Jobs

Freelance jobs are short-term or project-based work opportunities that allow individuals to work as independent contractors. Freelance jobs can range from writing, graphic design, copywriting, and web development, in addition to other service lines. Freelancers usually have more control over their schedules, rates and work content. However, they are responsible for their own taxes, health insurance, and other benefits.

D. Part-time Jobs

Part-time jobs are temporary jobs that offer fewer hours of work than full-time jobs in the same position. Part-time jobs have become increasingly popular in retail, healthcare, and hospitality industries. Part-time work can provide flexibility in work hours and more time for other activities outside of work. However, there are generally fewer benefits available for part-time employees.

Temporary Jobs vs Permanent Jobs

When it comes to employment, there are two main options to choose from: temporary jobs and permanent jobs. Each option has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, so it’s important to weigh the pros and cons before making a decision.

A. Overview of Differences

Temporary jobs, also known as contract or freelance work, are positions that typically have a set end date or are based on a project’s completion. The employee is employed by a staffing agency or directly by the company and is paid by the hour, week or month. On the other hand, permanent jobs are positions that are indefinite and offer more job security.

B. Pros and Cons of each type

Temporary jobs.

• Flexibility: Temporary jobs offer more flexibility, as you can pick which projects or contracts to work on and when to take breaks in between.
• Variety: Temporary jobs provide the opportunity to work in multiple industries or projects, which can broaden your skillset and resume.
• Higher pay: Temporary jobs often pay more because there are fewer benefits involved.
• Lack of Job Security: Temporary jobs do not provide the same level of job security as permanent jobs.
• No employer benefits: Temporary jobs typically do not offer benefits such as health insurance, sick leave or 401(k).
• Inconsistent workload: Temporary jobs sometimes have a fluctuating workload, which could lead to financial instability.

Permanent Jobs

• Job Stability: Permanent jobs provide job security and a consistent workload.
• Benefits: Permanent jobs offer employer benefits such as health insurance, vacation days, and retirement benefits.
• Opportunities for career growth: Permanent jobs provide opportunities to grow and build a career within the company.
• Less flexibility: Permanent jobs are less flexible in terms of work hours and projects.
• Limited industry experience: Permanent jobs within one specific company may limit your exposure to different industries.
• Lower pay: Permanent jobs typically have a lower hourly or contract rate compared to temporary jobs.

C. When to Choose Temporary Jobs and When to Choose Permanent Jobs

Deciding whether to take a temporary job or permanent job depends on the individual’s goals and priorities.

Choose a temporary job if:

• You are looking for higher paying job opportunities
• You value flexibility and variety in your projects
• You are not concerned with job stability in the long-term

Choose a permanent job if:

• You value job stability and predictability
• You want employer benefits such as health insurance and retirement plans
• You are looking for opportunities for career growth within a company

Both temporary jobs and permanent jobs offer unique advantages that are worth considering. It’s important to carefully assess one’s own situation and goals before making a decision.

Finding Temporary Jobs

There are several ways to find temporary job opportunities, and each method has its own set of advantages and disadvantages.

A. Traditional Job Search Methods

• One of the oldest and most established methods of job hunting.
• Can help you discover job openings that may not be advertised online.
• In-person interaction may give you the edge over other candidates.
• Limited access to job postings.
• Time-consuming to visit potential employers in person.
• May require transportation costs.

B. Online Job Search Methods

• Access to a wide range of job postings.
• Easy to search and apply for jobs.
• Allows you to apply to multiple job openings at once.
• Can be difficult to stand out from other applicants.
• Limited interaction with potential employers.
• May require time to sift through irrelevant job postings.

C. Recruitment Agencies

• Recruiting specialists who can offer personalized placement assistance.
• May have access to unadvertised job openings.
• Many agencies will handle the administrative side of employment, such as payroll and taxes.
• Agencies may focus more on filling their own company needs versus finding you the right job.
• Some agencies require an upfront fee.
• Not all agencies specialize in all industries.

D. Networking

• Personal referrals can give you an inside edge over other candidates.
• Connections with industry professionals can open up job opportunities.
• Can help you discover unadvertised job openings.
• Requires a lot of effort to build a strong professional network.
• May require attending events or joining industry associations to make connections.
• Connections may not always have leads on job opportunities.

There are several ways to find temporary job opportunities, and each method has its own set of advantages and disadvantages. It’s important to consider each option and determine which one is best suited for your needs and job search goals.

Applying for Temporary Jobs

Temporary jobs can be a great way to gain work experience, earn money, and explore different industries. However, before you begin your job search, it’s important to prepare your resume and cover letter, as well as brush up on your interviewing skills. In this section, we’ll cover:

A. Preparing your resume and cover letter

• Tailor your resume  to the specific job and industry. Highlight relevant skills and experiences that show you are a good fit for the temporary position.
• Include keywords  that match the job description to increase your chances of getting past the initial screening process.
• Be clear and concise  in presenting information about your background, education, work experiences, and other relevant details.
• Proofread  your resume and cover letter thoroughly for grammar and spelling errors, and format them in a professional-looking manner.

B. Interviewing tips

• Do your research  on the company and the job before the interview. Look at their website, mission statement, and other relevant information.
• Dress appropriately  for the interview. Dress professionally in business attire or in clothes that fit the company’s dress code.
• Arrive early  for the interview. This will give you enough time to adjust to the environment, fill out any necessary paperwork, and calm your nerves.
• Make eye contact  and be engaged during the interview. This shows you are interested in the position and the company.
• Be prepared to ask questions  about the company, the job, and your potential role.

C. Common temporary job interview questions

• Why are you interested in a temporary position?
• What relevant experience do you have for this temporary job?
• What are your strengths and weaknesses?
• What are your long-term career goals and how does this temporary position fit into them?
• Can you work flexible hours and handle changing job requirements?
• How do you handle difficult or stressful situations in the workplace?
• What motivates you to do your best work?

By following these tips and familiarizing yourself with common temporary job interview questions, you will be in a better position to succeed in your job search. Remember, temporary jobs have their pros and cons, but with the right preparation, you can use them to your advantage and advance your career.

Negotiating Pay and Benefits for Temporary Jobs

Temporary jobs may offer flexibility and experience, but negotiating pay and benefits is essential to ensure you are being compensated fairly. Here are some tips to help you negotiate pay and benefits for temporary jobs:

A. Understanding the market rates

Before negotiating pay and benefits, it’s important to research the current market rates for your role and industry. This will help you understand what you should be earning and what benefits you should be receiving. You can use online resources such as salary comparison websites, job boards, or speak with recruiters to get an idea of the current rates.

B. Negotiation techniques

When negotiating pay and benefits for temporary jobs, it’s essential to be clear on your expectations and what you can bring to the role. Here are some tips:

• Start by respectfully asking for what you think you are worth, but remain flexible.
• Highlight relevant experience and skills that you can bring to the position.
• Be confident and assertive but avoid being aggressive or confrontational.
• Consider non-monetary compensation such as vacation days or flexible work hours.

C. Common benefits offered in temporary jobs

Temporary jobs may not offer the same benefits as permanent positions, but there are some common benefits to look out for:

• Health and dental insurance: Some temporary positions may offer health and/or dental insurance as a benefit.
• Retirement plans: Some companies may offer a 401k or other retirement plan.
• Paid time off: Some temporary positions may offer vacation days or sick leave.
• Flexible work hours: Certain temporary positions may allow for flexible work hours which can be beneficial for those who need to balance work with other responsibilities.

Negotiating pay and benefits for temporary jobs is important to ensure you are being fairly compensated. Researching market rates, utilizing negotiation techniques, and being aware of common benefits offered can help you secure the best possible compensation package.

Making the most of Temporary Jobs

Temporary jobs can be an excellent way to gain valuable experience, earn some money, and even transition to a permanent position. In this section, we will cover three essential aspects of making the most of temporary jobs: impressing your employer, adapting to new environments, and using your temporary job to transition to a permanent position.

A. How to impress your employer

Impressing your employer is essential if you want to maximize your temporary job’s benefits. Here are some tips to help you make a great impression:

• Be punctual: Always arrive on time or, even better, a little early.
• Be professional: Dress appropriately for the job and maintain a positive attitude.
• Be proactive: Take the initiative to learn new things and ask questions.
• Be productive: Do your job to the best of your ability and take pride in your work.
• Be a team player: Work well with others and be willing to help out when needed.

By following these tips, you can show your employer that you are a responsible and valuable asset to their team.

B. Tips for adapting to new environments

Temporary jobs often require you to adapt to new environments quickly. Here are some tips to help you adjust:

• Be open-minded: Be willing to learn new things and try new approaches.
• Be observant: Pay attention to how things are done and what is expected of you.
• Be flexible: Be willing to adjust to changes in the work environment.
• Be social: Make an effort to meet and interact with your co-workers.

Adapting to a new environment can be challenging, but by taking an open and flexible approach, you can quickly become an integral part of the team.

C. How to use your temporary job to transition to a permanent position

One of the most significant advantages of temporary jobs is the potential for transitioning to a permanent position. Here are some steps you can take to increase your chances of landing a full-time job:

• Be reliable: Show up on time, do your job well, and be dependable.
• Be positive: Maintain a positive attitude and be a team player.
• Be proactive: Look for ways to go above and beyond your job duties.
• Be forward-thinking: Express your interest in a permanent position and ask about any opportunities for advancement.

By showing a genuine interest in the company and taking an active approach to your job, you can position yourself as a valuable candidate for a permanent position.

Making the most of temporary jobs requires you to impress your employer, adapt to new environments, and take steps to transition to a permanent position. By following these tips, you can turn your temporary job into a valuable opportunity for personal and professional growth.

Related Articles

• Visual Artist Job Description: A Complete Guide
• IT Assistant: Job Description, Salary, and Skills
• Best Assistant Manager Resume Examples
• 30 Electrician Resume Tips for Assistant Electricians
• Sample Answers to “Tell Me About a Time You Failed”

Rate this article

0 / 5. Reviews: 0

More from ResumeHead

Permanent Jobs vs. Temporary Jobs: What Is Right for You?

September 21, 2023.

In the current job market, job seekers must decide between pursuing permanent or temporary jobs, a crucial career choice. Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, but the choice greatly depends on an individual’s career goals, preferences, and circumstances. In this article, we’ll examine permanent and temporary job distinctions to aid your informed decision on the best fit for you.

Permanent Jobs: Stability and Long-Term Commitment

Advantages of permanent jobs:.

Stability: Permanent positions typically offer greater job security. Employees can rely on a steady income and often enjoy benefits like health insurance, retirement plans, and paid time off.

Career Growth : Many permanent jobs come with opportunities for career advancement and skill development. Companies often invest in the training and development of their long-term employees.

Sense of Belonging: Permanent employees often feel a stronger connection to their workplace and colleagues. They have a chance to become an integral part of the company culture.

Disadvantages of Permanent Jobs:

Limited Flexibility: Permanent positions may require a long-term commitment, which can limit your flexibility to explore other career options or pursue personal projects.

Risk of Stagnation: Some permanent roles may lead to complacency or stagnation if there is little room for growth or change within the organization.

Potential for Bureaucracy: Larger corporations may have more bureaucracy and hierarchical structures, which can limit your ability to make quick decisions or innovate.

Temporary Jobs: Flexibility and Diverse Experiences

Advantages of temporary jobs:.

Flexibility: Temporary positions are ideal for those seeking a more flexible work schedule or those looking to bridge employment gaps.

Diverse Experiences: Temporary roles can expose you to a variety of industries, companies, and projects, allowing you to build a broad skill set and network.

Freelance Opportunities: Temporary work can be a stepping stone to freelancing or starting your own business, offering you more control over your career.

Disadvantages of Temporary Jobs:

Income Uncertainty: Temporary work may not provide the same level of financial stability as permanent employment. Income can be irregular, depending on the nature and duration of assignments.

Limited Benefits: Temporary workers often receive fewer or no benefits compared to their permanent counterparts, which can impact financial security and access to healthcare.

Lack of Job Security : Temporary positions are inherently less secure, with no long-term guarantees. Job hunting may become a frequent occurrence.

Choosing What’s Right for You

The decision between permanent and temporary employment ultimately depends on your individual circumstances and career goals. Here are some factors to consider:

Your Career Stage: If you’re just starting your career or looking for a change, temporary roles can provide valuable experiences and help you explore different industries. More established professionals may prefer the stability of permanent employment.

Financial Stability: Assess your financial needs and how comfortable you are with income variability. If stability is a priority, permanent employment may be the better choice.

Long-Term Goals: Consider your long-term career aspirations. If you’re aiming for leadership positions and long-term job security, permanent roles may align better with your goals.

Work-Life Balance: Think about your work-life balance preferences. Temporary jobs can offer more flexibility, while permanent positions may require a stronger commitment.

Personal Values: Evaluate the importance of factors like company culture, benefits, and job security in relation to your personal values and priorities.

In the end, your career decision should harmonize with your personal goals and circumstances, whether it’s permanent or temporary employment. There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, as each option has its unique advantages and drawbacks. When the day concludes, it’s crucial to evaluate your preferences, conduct thorough research, and select the path that empowers your career journey. Remember, your career evolves; you can switch between these employment types as your needs and goals change.

About Comrise

At Comrise, we offer tailored solutions for the full-time, part-time, direct-hire, contract, and permanent talent that your business needs. For 39+ years, we have delighted our clients and candidates by focusing on customer satisfaction, innovation, and flexible workforce solutions! 

If you’re looking for new job opportunities click  here , or if you’re looking for a reliable partner to help you secure top-notch candidates for hard-to-fill roles, click  here .

Related Posts

Strategic budgeting and data mastery in engineering leadership, may 2, 2024.

Introduction In the dynamic realm of the engineering industry, the convergence of strategic budgeting and enhanced data quality practices marks a pivotal transformation. Insights drawn from recent Gartner reports reveal...

Malaysia Plans to Build SEA’s Largest IC Design Park

April 30, 2024.

Driving Malaysia’s Entrepreneurial Ecosystem: On April 22nd, the Malaysian government unveiled the KL20 Action Paper. This initiative aims to foster a vibrant entrepreneurial ecosystem in Malaysia. Consequently, the government plans...

Recruitment Trend Report Q1 2024 - China Market

April 23, 2024.

  Chinese Recruitment Market Overview: In the first quarter of 2024, under the background of high-quality development, China’s economic operation has shown a continuous recovery trend, which has promoted the...

All Rights Reserved Comrise 2020 | Website Built by Simplicity Design and Marketing

Global contact information.

We have offices across the globe. Please ensure that you are getting in touch with the correct office for your region.

United States

Woodbridge, nj (global hq).

90 Woodbridge Center Drive Suite 360 Woodbridge, NJ 07095 Tel: 1-732-739-2330 Fax: 1-732-739-1996

Philippines

Metro manila.

1105 Raffles Corporate Center, Ortigas Center, Pasig City, Metro Manila, Philippines

Kuala Lumpur

Unit B12, Level 1, Menara BT, Tower 3, Avenue 7, Horizon Phase 2, Bangsar South, No.8, Jalan Kerinchi, 59200 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

Tel: +60-03-27794130

Room 1015, 10/F, Hanweidasha Building, Guanghualu Road, Chaoyang District, Beijing,100020

Tel: +86 10 58780578

北京市朝阳区光华路7号汉威大厦东区1015室

邮编：100020 电话：+86 10 58780578

Room 822, 8F, Building 1, HNA Center, 234 Yan’an Third Road, Shinan District, Qingdao, China

Tel: +86 532 68669385

山东省青岛市海尔路182-8号半岛国际大厦2104室

邮编：266000 电话：+86 532 68669385

Room 18F/G/H, Shanghai Industrial Investment Building, No.18 Caoxi Road, Xuhui District, Shanghai, 200030

Tel: +86 21 64270570

上海市徐汇区漕溪北路18号上海实业大厦18楼F/G/H座

邮编：200030 电话：+86 21 64270570

26th Floor Bldg.2,No.88 Jitai 5th Road, Xiangnian Square, Tianfu Avenue, Hi-Tech Zone, Chengdu, Sichuan, 610041

Tel: +86 28 86703369

四川省成都市高新区天府大道中段吉泰五路88号香年广场T2座26层

邮编：610041 电话：+86 28 86703369

Wan Chai, Hong Kong

EA Licence no. 66051 & 64845

5/F Heng Shan Centre, 145 Queen’s Road East, Wan Chai, Hong Kong

Tel: +852 36223225

牌照号码: 66051 & 64845

香港湾仔皇后大道东145号恒山中心5楼

电话：+852 36223225

Room 1419, 14 / F, Building A, New World Center, No. 634, Jiefang Street, Qiaokou District, Wuhan, Hubei

C17, 18 / F, Block E, Chang’an International Center, 88 Nanguanzheng street, Xi’an, Shaanxi

A11-10, 1701, Building 7, Wanda Office Building, Wuhu Road, Hefei, Anhui

Change Language

Temporary vs. Permanent Employees

• Small Business
• Managing Employees
• ')" data-event="social share" data-info="Pinterest" aria-label="Share on Pinterest">
• ')" data-event="social share" data-info="Reddit" aria-label="Share on Reddit">
• ')" data-event="social share" data-info="Flipboard" aria-label="Share on Flipboard">

How to Pay Overtime in a Seasonal Landscape Business

How to build a manpower agency, objectives & strategies for labor costs.

• How to Calculate FMLA Hours With a Part-Time Employee
• The Relevance of Human Resource Compensation & Rewards

Building a strong team is one of the most challenging aspects of running a business. Before taking this step, make sure you understand the difference between permanent, temporary and casual work. Permanent employees are a long-term investment in your business and can help you build the foundation of a strong brand. Hiring temporary workers, on the other hand, provides more flexibility and involves lower costs.

Know Your Hiring Options

Whether you're starting a small business or growing your team, it's essential to understand the different types of employment out there. Should you hire permanent or temporary workers? What about contract workers and freelancers? The best option depends on your business goals and recruitment budget. As a small business owner, you may have both temporary and permanent employees – and outsource some functions, such as IT, accounting or human resources.

The Fair Labor Standards Act doesn't define full-time or part-time employment, states the U.S. Department of Labor . As an employer, it's your responsibility to determine what counts as full-time work and what's considered part-time work.

Note, though, that any work over 40 hours per week is considered overtime and must be paid as such. Some employees, including pilots and flight attendants, taxi drivers, livestock auction workers and others, are exempt from overtime pay requirements, according to the Fair Labor Standards Act Advisor .

The Bureau of Labor Statistics defines full-time employees as individuals who work at least 35 hours per week. Therefore, those working less than that can be considered part-time employees. For example, many companies hire part-time accountants, software developers, copywriters or network administrators.

As the IRS notes, any organization with more than 50 staff members must offer health insurance to those working an average of 30 hours per week. Permanent employment, whether part-time or full-time, requires medical coverage, pension plans, office space, workers' compensation, training and more. That's not the case with temporary and contract employees.

The main difference between a permanent and a temporary employee is that the temp workers, or casual staff, are hired for a predetermined period. This category may include freelancers, interim staff, seasonal workers or contract workers. In some instances, they may receive health insurance and other benefits, but that's not a hard rule.

Like permanent employees, temp workers are protected by law against discrimination and sexual harassment. Furthermore, employers and staffing agencies must take the steps needed to provide them with a safe work environment, states the Occupational Safety and Health Administration .

Hiring Temporary vs. Permanent Employees

Hiring permanent employees involves higher costs than temp work. Terminating them requires extensive paperwork and may not be easy from a legal standpoint. But this option has its perks. A permanent employee is more likely to be loyal to the company he works for and stay there when times get tough. He may also better understand your company's culture, mission and values than a seasonal or contractor worker.

Another difference between a permanent and a temporary job lies in the level of commitment. Permanent employees have the chance to grow professionally and develop their skills as your business grows. They may also put more time and effort into their work to get promoted and advance their careers. A temporary employee, on the other hand, may quit their job when you least expect it. Plus, they may work for several employers at a time, so they might not be able to fully commit to your projects.

A December 2017 study published in the European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology states that while temporary workers may benefit a company's bottom line, they may also hurt team performance and morale. To prevent these issues, managers should foster a culture of commitment and train their teams to embrace diversity.

All in all, temporary employment can be a good choice for short-term projects. This option allows you to recruit from a wider talent pool while reducing the time to hire. Plus, it's more cost-effective. Permanent employment, by comparison, makes it easier to build a strong company culture and secure a loyal workforce. A mix of temporary, permanent and contract employees may help your organization expand its reach and remain competitive.

• U.S. Department of Labor: Seasonal Employment / Part-Time Information
• U.S. Department of Labor: Overtime Pay
• U.S. Department of Labor: Fair Labor Standards Act Advisor
• Bureau of Labor Statistics: Full- or Part-Time Status
• IRS: Employers Subject to the Employer Shared Responsibility Provisions
• Occupational Safety and Health Administration: Protecting Temporary Workers
• European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology: Teaming up With Temps: The Impact of Temporary Workers on Team Social Networks and Effectiveness

Andra Picincu is a digital marketing consultant with over 10 years of experience. She works closely with small businesses and large organizations alike to help them grow and increase brand awareness. She holds a BA in Marketing and International Business and a BA in Psychology. Over the past decade, she has turned her passion for marketing and writing into a successful business with an international audience. Current and former clients include The HOTH, Bisnode Sverige, Nutracelle, CLICK - The Coffee Lover's Protein Drink, InstaCuppa, Marketgoo, GoHarvey, Internet Brands, and more. In her daily life, Ms. Picincu provides digital marketing consulting and copywriting services. Her goal is to help businesses understand and reach their target audience in new, creative ways.

Related Articles

How many hours can a temporary employee work per year, what things do we need to consider when staffing, how temp agencies work, how to set a finder's fee with temporary agencies, what is an active employee, the disadvantages of 12-hour work shifts, does an employer have to pay social security tax for a contracted employee, how many hours is considered part-time employment, five mandatory benefits for full-time employees, most popular.

• 1 How Many Hours Can a Temporary Employee Work Per Year?
• 2 What Things Do We Need to Consider When Staffing?
• 3 How Temp Agencies Work
• 4 How to Set a Finder's Fee With Temporary Agencies

• Why DataCheck
• Testimonials
• Background Investigation
• Identity Verification
• Qualification Verifications
• Motor Vehicle Records
• Sanctions Searches
• Drug Screening
• Social Media Searches
• Credit Report
• International Searches
• ATS / HRIS Integration
• Manufacturing
• Food Services
• Sports & Entertainment
• Hospitality
• Compliance and Security
• Sample Report
• Request Pricing
• Customer Login

When to Hire a Temp vs. Permanent Employee

Personnel decisions are some of the most important decisions to be made when running a business. Those staffing decisions, such as hiring temporary employees vs. full-time employees, are essential aspects of effective management. Several factors have to be considered when deciding if you want to handle your staffing needs through temporary or permanent employees. Understanding scheduling strategies, long-term vs. short-term staffing needs and other financial forecasting tools can help you make the right hiring decision.

What is a Temporary Employee?

Before we dive into the benefits and drawbacks of hiring temporary vs. permanent employees in your business, we should make sure to have a sound understanding of what the terms mean. You know what a permanent employee is. However, the term “temporary employees” can have a somewhat variable meaning. First of all, temporary employees are those employees who hold a position that is set to last for a short, predetermined period.

There are no fundamental guidelines that determine how long temporary employment has to last. For instance, some retail stores may want to increase their available labor during the Christmas season, so they hire temporary employees starting in November and take them off the schedule around the New Year. 

Other examples of temporary employment include small businesses that use the services of a temporary employment agency to fill temporarily replace an employee who has taken an extended period off due to the birth of a child, an illness, or another unexpected situation.

If you decide to use temporary employees, you must do so the right way. Make sure that the employee understands that there is an end date to their employment with your company. Failure to do so is not only unethical, but it could potentially lead to litigation.

Temporary vs. Permanent: The Pros and Cons of Each

As is the case with any staffing decision, the decision between using temporary vs. permanent employees must include an evaluation of the pros and cons of each side of the coin. Ultimately, hiring temporary employees vs. full-time will depend on the type of business you run, your budgeting abilities, and a myriad of other factors.

Pros of Temporary Employees

• Temporary employees can help meet your company’s short-term needs through a unique skill set that they possess. Hypothetically, let’s say that you’re implementing a new computer program in your business. A temporary employee who is well-versed in that program can help train your employees, setting them up for long-term success.
• Temporary employment provides networking opportunities. First of all, you can establish a professional relationship with a temporary hiring agency that can funnel employees to you. Additionally, the temporary employees you bring in may prove to be valuable contacts that later turn into permanent employees.
• In some cases, temporary employees can reduce hiring costs.
• Background checks, drug tests and other pre-employment screenings can be costly. If you allow a temporary employment agency to vet your temporary employees for you, it can save you money.
• Speaking of vetting employees, temporary employment agencies usually do background checks. These checks can help you avoid making bad hires.

Cons of Temporary Hires

• Training temporary employees can be time-consuming and costly. This is especially problematic if their employment will be for an especially short-term.
• Temporary employees often require a higher salary or hourly pay rate. These employees know that you’re hiring them because you’re in a position of need. They also know they won’t receive extra benefits and therefore can require higher pay.
• Temporary employees often work for multiple companies at the same time. This means that your company may not have its full attention and energy.
• Temporary employees may leave for higher-paying or permanent positions with little-to-no notice.

Pros of Permanent Employees

• Permanent employees are often more motivated than temporary employees. When people know they have the potential to advance within the company, they may work harder.
• Permanent employees may perform better due to being under less stress. When people know they have a stable work situation, they’re not as worried about the future.
• As an employer, you’re also under less stress with permanent employees. You can forecast for the future since you know who makes up your team.
• Speaking of teams, you can create a culture of stability by hiring permanent employees.

Cons of Permanent Employees

• You may be required to provide benefits to permanent employees if they work full time. Paying for various types of insurance, paid time off, and other benefits can prove costly.
• Depending on your state’s laws, it can be difficult to fire a permanent employee. Moving on from permanent employees can require extensive paperwork and other costs.
• Pre-employment vetting can be very expensive. Background checks, drug tests and other pre-employment steps not only require money but they’re also time-consuming.
• Employees may get bored performing the same tasks every day for years at a time. This can lead to diminished work quality.

While permanent employees are still more common among most business owners, there is certainly something to be said for temporary employment. Every company’s staffing needs are different, and each employer’s goals may vary.

Make Hiring Decisions Easy With DataCheck

Regardless of the hiring strategy that you choose, we have the solutions that you’re looking for. DataCheck has helped countless employers with pre-hiring screening and background checks they need to keep their business operating. With advanced background screening, you can rest assured that you’ll find the right candidate for your job openings. 

• Like us on Facebook
• Follow us on Twitter
• Connect with us on LinkedIn
• Check us out on Instagram
• Check us out on Tiktok

Employee Connect Apply Now

• Working For HCR
• Permanent Search
• Employment Documents
• Why Work With HCR?
• Search Jobs
• General Labour
• Machine Operator

Increase your knowledge and get better results.

We provide the resources you need for hiring and job search success.

Permanent vs. Temporary Employment: Which Is Right for You?

May 25th, 2021

Which is better: permanent or temporary employment? Ultimately, it helps to weigh the pros and cons of both employment options. That way, you can pursue perm or temp jobs that align with your skillset and career interests.

What’s the Difference Between Permanent and Temporary Jobs?

A permanent job refers to a position in which you are a part- or full-time salaried employee. The job involves a contract that stipulates the number of hours you work each week.

Comparatively, a temporary job is a position in which you work for a designated amount of time. A temp job can last anywhere from a few days to several months. Upon completing your assignment, you are free to reenter the job market and pursue a position elsewhere. In some instances, an employer may offer to extend the length of a temp job agreement. An employer may even provide a permanent job offer to a temp worker, too.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Permanent Employment?

Permanent jobs often include health insurance, dental insurance, and other perks unavailable with temporary roles. Thus, these jobs can provide greater financial security and peace of mind in contrast to temp positions.

Furthermore, with a perm job, a worker can lay the groundwork for a successful career with a single business. If an employee performs well in a perm role, he or she can climb the corporate ladder. This ensures the employee can advance their career and optimize their earnings.

There is a lot to like about perm jobs, but there are downsides to consider, too. For instance, a permanent job can be monotonous. It may cause workers to feel like they are stuck in a routine, particularly if they perform the same tasks day after day.

Meanwhile, perm employees may feel the need to work long hours. This can inadvertently contribute to burnout and an unhealthy work-life balance .

What Are the Pros and Cons of Temporary Employment?

Whereas a permanent role ties you to one company for as long as you or the business chooses, a temp job offers greater flexibility. In a temp role, you are obligated to work for a business for a set amount of time. Following this period, you can do whatever you’d like for work.

A temp job also provides the flexibility to work at hours that are convenient for you. Therefore, it may be an ideal option for students or parents.

Conversely, temp jobs do not offer a guaranteed salary for an extended period of time. There is no guarantee an employer will extend a temp job or offer a permanent position after a contract is completed, either.

Temp employees generally don’t receive the same benefits provided to permanent workers. As such, a temp worker likely won’t qualify for sick leave, holiday pay, and other perks.

Struggling to Decide Between Permanent and Temporary Employment? HCR Personnel Solutions Can Help

HCR can help you weigh the pros and cons of permanent and temporary employment options. Plus, we can keep you up to date regarding perm and temp roles in the Greater Toronto Area and Southwestern Ontario. To learn more, please contact us today .

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Notify me of follow-up comments by email.

Notify me of new posts by email.

Job Seekers

Find the Best Job to further your career.

Search All Jobs

Find the Best People for your organization.

Latest News

How to get along with your co-workers, we serve businesses in:.

• Tillsonburg
• Mississauga

Temporary vs Permanent Work, Which is Right for You?

Temporary vs permanent work. One of the ultimate employment conundrums. When it comes to deciding which type of work is right for you, choosing between temporary and permanent employment can be difficult, to say the least . It’s like choosing between meal prepping and committing to one meal for the week or popping into the shops every day on the way back from work and deciding on what to have when you get there.

Both have their benefits , and the type of role you ultimately choose will depend on several factors , including earning potential, stability, and flexibility, to name just three. Fortunately for you, that’s where we’re here to help! In this post, we’ll explore how to determine which option is right for you.   

What is Temporary Work ?

As the name suggests, temporary work is carried out over a fixed period rather than indefinitely. It is – by its very nature – work that will end. Data from 2021 showed approximately 1.71 million temporary employees in the United Kingdom.   

There are a couple of types of temporary work from which to choose. Firstly, you can commence on a fixed-term contract ; an example of this would be a nurse carrying out a 12-week contract, a six-month contract or a 12-month contract.   

The second option is what’s known as working on an ad hoc basis. These jobs are typically charged on an hourly or daily basis and over a much shorter period.

Temporary positions are also sometimes known as locum roles; locum comes from the Latin phrase locum tenens, which means “place holding”. That one’s for all you history nerds, out there!

Why Should You Consider a Temporary Position ?

Temporary work brings with it many benefits, including:    

Greater Flexibility

One of the most significant advantages of temporary work is undoubtedly the flexibility it brings. You can pick contracts that work around your life rather than vice versa.

The Ability for People to Travel

When your work is limited to a few weeks or months, there’s less need to settle if you don’t want to.

This makes temporary work ideal for people wanting a more nomadic lifestyle or who like to experience a wider variety of working environments. If travelling the country or the globe is your goal, then temporary work provides the goalposts.

The Option of  Temp Work Turning into Perm Work

If a temp position goes well, it can often lead to more extended temp contracts or even a permanent position in some instances. Now, of course, this isn’t something that everyone wants.

After all, some people want temporary work to stay, well – temporary. However, if the temp worker is a good fit with the employer, then there’s no reason why that relationship can’t potentially extend further down the line.

Are there any Drawbacks to Temporary Work ?

Temp work isn’t for everybody, with one person’s amazing flexibility being another person’s daunting instability. With temporary work, there’s much less salary stability, and when one temporary contract ends, the quest is on for the next one right away.   

There’s also potentially less scope for career progression with a temporary contract. Unlike permanent positions, which give you a solid footing from which to work your way up the job ladder gradually, temporary positions don’t offer the same foundation.   

That’s not to say that there’s no room for progression, however. As touched upon, short contracts can lead to longer contracts, which can, in turn, lead to even longer contracts. However, there’s less scope for progression (if such an opportunity exists) when an employer knows you will only be with them for a finite period. 

What is Permanent Work ?

Unlike temporary work, which has an endpoint from the outset, permanent work is ongoing, with no end date in the employment contract. Such positions typically offer an annual salary that’s paid monthly.   

Permanent work is much more common in the UK than temporary work. As per data from Gov.uk , almost 95% of all working-age people (in 2021) were employed in permanent job roles.

What are the Benefits of a Permanent Role ?

Just as temporary work has its benefits, so too does permanent work. The significant advantages of permanent work include:

Greater Job Security

If you ask anybody working in a permanent position why they chose that over a temporary role, the answer will be almost unanimous. Working somewhere indefinitely offers greater job security than working something for a fixed period.

If you work permanently for an employer, you can bank on the fact that, in a year and a half’s time, for example, you’ll still have a paycheck coming in at the end of that month. If you’re only working a three-month fixed contract, by contrast, then you’re having to work out where your income is going to come from almost as soon as you start the first job.

Scope for Career Progression

By working permanently somewhere, you’re laying down roots. The mightiest trees grow from the smallest of saplings, and they do so by planting their roots and letting them grow.

You can think of your progression through a company like the journey of a sapling into a mighty Oak. If you relocate the tree every few months, it’s less likely to reach the same heights .

Training Opportunities

If you work permanently for an employer, they’re more likely to invest in you as an employee, as you aren’t as likely to ship off somewhere else in the near future as a temporary worker will. This investment can take many forms, with training and development opportunities being one such area .

If we think of the permanent role as giving you that one, guaranteed sunny spot in the garden, then training opportunities can be thought of as the fertiliser or the watering can that’s needed to continually keep th at growth going .

Are there any Disadvantages to Permanent Work?

If you’ve started in a permanent role, it’s less likely that you’ll be able to swap that for a temporary role in the same way that a temporary role can eventually lead to a permanent position with an employer.   

Reduced flexibility is another drawback of a permanent role. If temporary work is like renting a property, then permanent work is akin to buying your home. It’s less easy to move around when you buy compared with when you rent, and the same can be said for permanent work when compared with temporary.   

Temporary vs Permanent Work – Which is Right for Me?

Ultimately, when it comes to choosing temporary vs permanent work, this is only a decision that you can make. But by using the above as guidance, you should now have a better understanding of the options on offer and which style of work is more aligned with your goals and desires.  

If you love flexibility and the option to work in various places, then a temporary contract is probably best. By contrast, if you want greater job security and a potentially greater scope for career progression, then a permanent role could be what you lean towards.   

Carry on reading

The Friday Five (23/02/24)

Are you looking for the latest news across healthcare, social care, education, or recovery and...

7 Good Questions to Ask Recruiters

Picture this. You’ve applied for a job, and a few minutes later, you receive a...

The Friday Five (16/02/24)

Looking for the latest news items in social care, healthcare, education, or recovery and criminal...

Are Cover Letters Really Necessary?

In today’s frantic employment world, jobs often get filled almost as quickly as they come...

The staff you need, exactly when you need them.

1.855.426.9757 | Supplier Registration | Login

• Visibility & Control
• Talent Acquisition
• Cost Management
• Risk Mitigation
• Process Optimization
• Contingent Workforce Advisory
• Managed Services (MSP)
• VMS Technology Advisory
• HR Advisory & Talent Acquisition
• Talent Pool Management
• IC Payment & Compliance
• Government & Public Sector
• SOW Management
• VMS Expertise
• Service & Quality
• Vendor & Technology Neutral
• Flexible Solutions
• Access to Top Talent
• Negotiation & Cost Savings
• How We Deliver
• Track Record
• Supplier Registration
• Self-Assessment Survey
• Workforce Management
• White Papers
• Case Studies
• Whiteboard Sessions

HCMWorks Insights

What is the Difference Between Permanent, Temporary and Contract Work?

To beat the shortage in skilled workers it’s likely that your organization has begun to create an agile and flexible workforce - making use of the highly-skilled and growing number of contingent workers .

Unfortunately, however, a large number of organizations are struggling to classify their workers properly. Many managers lack the necessary knowledge and time needed to fully understand the difference between permanent and the various groups of non-permanent workers.

Generally speaking, there are three categories of workers that your company can work with - permanent, temporary and contract workers. While many companies separate workers into two groups, permanent employees and non-permanent workers, there are significant differences between all of these groups of workers.

In fact, referring to temporary workers as contractors or the other way round could lead to issues for your business. That’s why it’s incredibly important that you get the description of your workers correct, and that you have complete clarity into the type of position they are filling in your organization.

So, what exactly is the difference between permanent, temporary and contract workers, and how can you ensure your company is managing its mixed workforce correctly? We explain all in this blog.

A permanent employee is someone that works with your company on a permanent employee contract. Permanent work also includes fixed-term contracts, where the employee is paid through the employer’s payroll.

Permanent workers are eligible for employee benefits, such as paid vacations, sick days, bonuses and a wide range of other perks that are given to permanent employees as part of an employer’s workforce retention strategy.

Temporary workers are generally provided to your company through either a staffing agency or a human capital firm. These workers are employees to the staffing agency, but classified as a temporary worker for your organization.

A temporary worker will receive an hourly wage from the staffing company, as well as potential benefits such as vacation, health insurance at retirement plans - but your business will not be responsible for any of these.

Since there is a contract of services for an agreed hourly rate, temporary workers must be paid overtime when applicable.

While temporary workers and contract workers are both part of the contingent workforce, which makes up the wider gig economy, there are significant differences between these classifications of workers.

Unlike temporary workers who are paid an hourly rate, true contract workers (independent contractors)are self-employed and should be paid a flat amount by a company for the completion of a specific project or pre-determined deliverable.

These workers should be able to choose their own hours and can work from where they want, whether that be at their employer’s office, home, or a location of their choosing. They are responsible for calculating and paying their own taxes.

Unlike temporary workers, independent contractors usually do not fill out timesheets and are paid for the work they do, not the time they work. That means they are responsible for delivering a product or service by a specific deadline and shouldn’t be paid any extra no matter how many hours they spend working on it.

How to manage a mixed workforce

If you are in the procurement or HR department of a large organization, it’s highly likely that you are responsible for the management of your company’s workforce. However, managing a mixed workforce is highly complex - and it’s unlikely you either have the resources or expertise to do so successfully.

In fact, here at HCMWorks , most of the contingent workforce management programs that we see are disorganized - leading to inefficient practices, expensive errors, a lack of visibility and control, fragmented process, poor hiring choices and much more.

A managed services provider (MSP) with expertise in the contingent workforce, however, will give you all the tools and knowledge your company needs to streamline the management of your contingent workforce supply chain.

This will allow your organization to have complete visibility and control into your workforce, allowing you to hit those workforce targets. Not only that, but a proper contingent workforce management strategy will help you to improve compliance, significantly reduce costs, save wasted time and implement a clear human capital strategy that empowers your company’s growth.

Are you looking to gain more visibility into your entire workforce, both contingent and permanent, but don’t know where to start? Contact HCMWorks today and find out how our workforce advisory and management solutions can revolutionize your company.

Tags: Contingent Workforce

Get Updates

Popular posts, popular tags.

• Contingent Workforce (88)
• Workforce Management (72)
• Contingent Workforce Management (66)
• Independent Contractors (53)
• Procurement (34)

• HR & Talent Acquisition

United States

136 Madison Avenue, 6th Floor   New York, NY 10016 Canada

2 St. Clair Avenue West, 18th Floor  Toronto, ON M4V 1L5

1.855.426.9757 [email protected] Supplier Registration

• Four Recruitment
• Find a role
• Recruit for a role
• Internal Roles
• Salary Guide
• Charity & Events

Temporary Employment vs Permanent Employment

When applying for jobs, you may have the opportunity to choose between a temporary and permanent role. Both options have their pros and cons, so it’s important you consider both options before choosing one.

In this article, we discuss permanent and temporary contracts, and explain the difference between the two.

What is a temporary employee?

A temporary employee has a job that lasts for a defined, short period of time. The time frame can be as little as a few days to a few weeks.

In some cases, temporary employees may be covering longer periods of time, for example, to cover other staff members taking maternity leave.

What is a temporary contract of employment?

Temporary contracts of employment are agreements that have a start and end date. Temporary contracts can be extended and subject to change too.

Even though it is still a short term contract, temporary employees are still entitled to the same rights as all other staff, including sick pay and holiday allowance.

Temporary contracts allow you to pursue other interests or gain experience within specific sectors. They are also a great way to meet various people and create contacts, which may help you find your next job.

What is a permanent employee?

A permanent employee has a long term job role without a predetermined end date. You may be in this role for months, years or even for your whole career. A permanent employee can work on either a full-time or part-time basis.

Some of the most common motives for permanent employment include:

• You want to commit to a long term position to plan your career
• You rely on your employer for a range of different benefits.

What is the difference between a permanent and a temporary contract?

The main difference between a permanent and temporary contract is that temporary contracts usually have a defined date for when your employment with the company will end.

However, there are other differences too. In order to pursue the best type of job role which works for you, make sure you know the differences.

Payroll taxes

Employers will handle payroll taxes for both permanent and temporary employees, but the conditions are slightly different. Companies will always handle payroll taxes when hiring permanent staff, and in most cases, staffing agencies will also manage payroll taxes for temporary employees.

However, seasonal workers hired directly by companies will likely have to pay their taxes independently.

Do temporary employees have the same rights as permanent employees?

Yes, temporary employees have the same basic employment rights and working conditions as permanent employees.

This includes rights such as sick pay, holiday allowance and any other benefits the company has.

Pros and cons of temporary employment

In order to help you make a decision on what type of employment is best for you, we’ve broken down some of the pros and cons of temporary and permanent employment for candidates below.

Pros of temporary employment

• Temporary jobs offer flexibility : One of the great things about temporary employment is that you can tailor jobs to fit your schedule, choosing to work as many or few hours as you want. This is ideal for those who want to try out a job without making a commitment to it.
• You can learn new skills : If you’re looking to start a new career and learn new skills, temporary work can help you. Temping is a great way to gain necessary skills and build out your skill set for a long term career.
• It can help you fill out employment gaps : Some people are reluctant to take on temporary work as they fear it won’t look good on their CV, but this couldn’t be further from the truth. In reality, temporary employment is a great way to showcase skills you’ve learned and how they will help you in new roles.

If you are an employer and are wondering whether offering temporary roles would benefit your business, we have another blog on the Benefits of Temporary Employment , with specific reference to how employers could benefit.

Cons of temporary employment

• The job is short term : Temporary roles are not meant to be ongoing and will usually range from a few days to a few weeks. Whilst it is possible for them to last longer , if you are looking for a career, a temp job is not a sure bet.
• Temp work may not be exciting : Temp jobs can typically be monotonous. Due to their short term nature, temp jobs are usually fairly simple and do not offer much variety.
• They may offer lower pay:  The majority of temporary jobs are entry-level and short-term in nature, so they tend to have lower salaries. This may be a deal breaker for some, but if you’re looking to avoid the strains that unemployment may bring, temp jobs can be a great option.

Pros and cons of permanent employment

Pros of permanent employment.

• Room for progression : Permanent jobs frequently come with benefits such as room for progression into a more senior role. This is usually within the organisation you already work for.
• No end date : Another advantage is that there is no contractual end date, which adds to the stability of a job role. If you want to leave, or your boss wants you to, you will have to adhere to the notice period stated in your contract which should give you some time to find a new job.
• Employee benefits : There’s more likely to be more employee benefits with permanent roles compared to temporary roles. This may include health discounts, extra holiday entitlement and rewards for hitting certain targets.

Cons of permanent employment

• Working hours : Working days and hours of permanent roles are likely to be less flexible than temporary work. However, due to the pandemic, this may have changed depending on the company.
• Repetitive work : The work you do may be repetitive and can get tedious. Performing in the same roles, in the same environment every day can be tiring.

If you’re considering a temporary position , or are still struggling to decide which path is best for you, our team of recruitment consultants can help you. Get in touch with us today for support with employment.

You can also see what temporary roles are available on our site.

FAQs about temporary and permanent employment

What is the difference between seasonal and temporary employment.

Temporary workers will typically work short periods of time, any time of the year, whilst seasonal workers are hired to work in periods of increased business, such as during Christmas or summer holidays.

What is the difference between temporary and contract employment?

If you are hired on a temporary contract, you will typically be employed for a fixed amount of time to cover illnesses, maternity/paternity leave and potentially increased workload.

You will be paid by the company, who will have agreed an hourly or daily rate in your contract.

If you’re hired on a contract however, an umbrella company will act as your employer whilst you produce the work for a business. Instead of the company directly paying you, you will be paid via the umbrella company.

Share:         

Why should you work with a recruitment agency exclusively?

The past year we have seen a significant transformation in the recruitment landscape leaving...

Interview Etiquette in 2024

Now we know this topic is basic and fundamental and we don’t want to teach people how to...

Introducing Four Tech: The Ideal Hub for Ambitious Tech Talent

Introducing FourTech: The Ideal Hub for Ambitious Tech Talent When ambition meets opportunity,...

View all news »

0208 245 1192

• Sep 20, 2023

When Does A Temporary Employee Become Permanent: Everything You Need To Know

Updated: Nov 28, 2023

In the ever-evolving landscape of employment, the line between temporary and permanent positions has become increasingly blurred.

Gone are the days when a temporary job was simply a stepping stone to something more substantial.

Instead, companies are redefining what it means to be a temporary employee, leading us to question:

How Long Can You Be A Temporary Employee?

In the UK, being a temporary employee can offer various benefits, such as flexibility and exposure to different industries and job roles.

However, many individuals often wonder how long they can remain in this temporary status.

While there isn't a set maximum duration for being a temporary employee in the UK, it is important to understand that your employment rights may differ depending on your length of service.

Under current UK employment law, once you have been employed by the same employer for 12 continuous weeks or more through an agency, you may be entitled to certain additional rights and benefits afforded by permanent employees.

These rights could include paid time off for sickness or annual leave, as well as access to workplace pension schemes.

It's worth noting that continuous service does not necessarily mean working full-time hours; part-time and flexible workers can also accrue this service over time.

The length of time temporary employees can work in a temporary role ultimately depends on various factors, such as the terms of the contract you have with your employer or agency.

Some individuals prefer the flexibility offered by short-term employment arrangements, while others may seek longer-term stability.

Above all else, understanding your rights and communicating openly with your employer or agency are crucial steps towards making informed decisions regarding your future prospects as a temporary employee in the UK.

Understanding The Difference Between Temporary And Permanent Employees.

Temporary and permanent employees play very specific roles within an organization, and it is crucial to understand the differences between the two.

Temporary employees are typically hired for a specific project or period, allowing companies to quickly fill immediate staffing gaps without making long-term commitments.

They offer flexibility and the ability to scale up or down according to business needs. On the other hand, permanent employees are more deeply integrated into an organization or brand.

They work on an ongoing basis and often have access to benefits like healthcare, retirement plans, and paid time off.

Although it may seem that hiring permanent employees is always the better choice, there are situations where temporary hires can add tremendous value.

Temporary workers bring specialized skills that may not be required on a day-to-day basis.

For example, hiring seasonal staff during peak periods can help businesses efficiently manage increased demand without burdening their regular workforce with additional workload or organizations facing financial constraints might find that employing temporary workers allows them to reduce costs while still completing critical tasks.

Understanding when to hire temporary or permanent employees depends on various factors such as budget constraints, workflow demands, company vision, and available resources.

By carefully evaluating these factors, businesses can optimize their workforce composition for maximum productivity and success in achieving organizational goals.

Ultimately, having a mix of both temporary and permanent employees provides companies with flexibility when adapting to changing market conditions while ensuring they have a stable core group of talented individuals driving long-term growth.

When Does A Temporary Worker Become Entitled To A Permanent Contract?

There is often a lingering question about when a temporary worker becomes entitled to the same rights as permanent staff.

In the UK, there exists AWR (Agency Worker's Rights) after 3 months and after 2 years. If the person is working through an agency that stipulates after working in a temporary position for 3 months or 2 years, individuals may gain access to the same rights as a permanent member of staff in the same comparable role. Let's discuss both options below in more detail.

Agency Workers' Rights in the UK:

After 3 Months:

Equal Treatment: Agency workers are entitled to equal treatment compared to permanent employees in the same role.

Pay: They should receive the same basic pay, including overtime and related allowances.

Working Hours: Agency workers have the right to the same working hours and rest breaks as permanent employees.

After 2 Years:

Access to Vacancies: They must be informed of job vacancies and given a fair chance to apply for permanent positions.

Terms and Conditions: Agency workers may be entitled to similar non-pay-related benefits as permanent employees, such as leave entitlements.

Note: Agency workers do not automatically become permanent employees but have these rights to ensure fair treatment during their assignments. Regulations may change, so stay updated and seek legal advice if necessary.

However, please note that these rules are not universally applied and can differ depending on the location and specific employment laws.

It is important for both employees and employers to understand these regulations in order to navigate the transition from temporary to permanent status effectively.

While the 4-year rule may provide some security for long-term temporary workers, it should be noted that it does not automatically guarantee them a permanent contract. Instead, it grants these employees the right to request such an arrangement.

Employers may still have valid reasons for denying this request, such as financial constraints or changes in business needs.

Additionally, some jurisdictions deviate from this rule altogether, leaving many temporary workers without any clear pathway towards permanency.

In today's ever-changing job market, where flexibility and temporary work are increasingly common, it's crucial for both employees and employers to consider alternative arrangements beyond simply waiting out the 4-year mark.

Open communication between parties can foster discussions about potential pathways towards permanency earlier on in an employee's tenure with the company.

This proactive approach allows employers to evaluate their workforce needs more realistically while supporting employees' expectations and aspirations at the same time.

Ultimately, finding a balance between stability and adaptability is key in managing the transition from temporary to permanent positions.

Factors Influencing The Decision To Make An Employee Permanent

When it comes to making an employee permanent, there are several factors that employers take into consideration. One key factor is the individual's performance and ability to meet job expectations.

Employers look for consistent, high-quality work, a strong work ethic, and a willingness to go above and beyond.

Another factor that influences the decision is the employee's potential for growth within the company.

Employers often consider whether the individual has shown ambition, a desire to learn new skills, and a willingness to accept additional responsibilities.

If an employee demonstrates these qualities, then they are more likely to be offered a permanent position.

Additionally, cultural fit plays a significant role in determining whether an employee will be made permanent. Employers seek individuals who can integrate well with their team and align with the organization's values and goals.

The ability to collaborate effectively with coworkers and engage positively in workplace dynamics demonstrates that an individual can contribute not only as an individual but also as part of a larger team.

Conclusion: Key Considerations For Employers And Employees

In conclusion, determining when a temporary employee becomes permanent is not always a clear-cut decision.

It requires careful consideration of various factors, such as the duration and nature of the employment, the intentions of both parties and the relevant legal regulations.

Employers should be mindful of their obligations to provide benefits and protections once an employee has reached permanent status.

Employees should also be aware of their rights and advocate for themselves if they believe they have met the criteria for becoming permanent.

By understanding these key considerations, employers and employees can navigate this transition effectively and ensure fair treatment in the workplace.

Recent Posts

The Ultimate Guide To Writing A Persuasive Personal Statement

Leading by Example: Navigating Work-Life Balance As A Manager

Understanding the Basics of CVs: Key Elements, Structure, and Mistakes to Avoid

Comentarios

Tesla vs Tesla: US carmaker sues Indian namesake for copying trademark

• Medium Text

• Company Tesla Inc Follow

Sign up here.

Reporting by Arpan Chatruvedi and Aditya Kalra; Editing by Sharon Singleton

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles. New Tab , opens new tab

Thomson Reuters

Arpan is a correspondent for Reuters based in New Delhi, where he reports from the courts in India. He joined Reuters in 2022, and has been a part of the companies coverage team reporting on court cases spanning aviation, mining, human rights and other public interest issues.

Aditya Kalra is the Company News Editor for Reuters in India, overseeing business coverage and reporting stories on some of the world's biggest companies. He joined Reuters in 2008 and has in recent years written stories on challenges and strategies of a wide array of companies -- from Amazon, Google and Walmart to Xiaomi, Starbucks and Reliance. He also extensively works on deeply-reported and investigative business stories.

World Chevron

Switzerland won Eurovision's jury vote, while viewers favoured Croatia, Israel

Swiss artist Nemo won the grand final of the Eurovision Song Contest on Saturday, beating 24 rivals with the song "The Code", while Israel's Eden Golan finished fifth despite calls for a boycott over the war in Gaza.